That VL sits there day in day out. It is in shocking condition. All the paint is peeling and its just generally untidy. I cant imagine a proper enthusiast would treat his pride and joy like that. As a member of an approved club I haven't put my Datsun on the scheme because it needs the bonnet resprayed.
It doesn't matter how you think an enthusiast would treat his car, it's up to the owner.
My D21 is on club permit and the paint is really rough, mechanically though it is spot on. It sits on the street and will run out of days on the permit if I keep using it as much as I do at the moment. I quite like the way it looks and once a few of the other projects are out of the way it will get the body work/paint done. Until then I am more than happy driving around in a ratty looking Navara.
My wifes E30 323i is on a club permit, It sits on the street and is driven about 80 times a year. It isn't worth selling because it isn't worth more than a couple of grand and it is too handy to have as a spare car (and she loves it) but we wouldn't keep it if it costs us $700+ a year to register. On CPS it is affordable to keep and use.
If the car is 25 years old it qualifies for the CPS, if it is safe and meets with Vicroads regulations for modifications and passes a scrutineers inspection/rwc it can have a permit on it.
Your opinion (or mine or anyone's) does not matter as long as the owner complies with the requirements of the CPS.
what happens with later efi engines converted or running or carbs and no pollution gear??
You would have to have the car engineered to get it on the CPS.